@jannex: I host that server for this guy
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5d2e0/5d2e04353e8ee2fe69da63b89eade9c271d79ff0" alt="user"
You can try to contact him for help and try with the creator of the original tibia script. Also it would help if you posted the logs of a failed join attempt here. (Start new game, try to join, open console and copy/paste content).
What would definitely help is to reset the server, but that would mean your level will also be 0 again :S
Edit: I can't join anymore now either ;). Got the exact same problem as you and probably a lot more people since almost noone is playing anymore!